Her vocal mentor is The One who praised her as his most memorable student. Her hometown is Jeonrado Jeonju. She learned how to play guitar for that role. Taeyeon collects perfumes. Tayeon loves jelly, gummy worms and the likes. Taeyeon's talents came from her parents Her dad was a vocalist in a band, and mom had won children's song competitions when she was young. Taeyeon's parents are very supportive. They let their children decide for themselves. Honestly there are members that would be better leaders but I think she did not that bad job at the end, other girls seem to respect her as a leader and even if she lacked at some things, she tried.
Because she's irresponsible,problematic and racists. A leader isn't supposed to display that to her members at all. How are you going to be more scandalous when your the leader? She's one of the worst leaders in k-pop. Even if she refuses to be the leader, I guess her position as leader is still official in SM?
Unless SM releases a statement that she's not the leader anymore. Have you ever played on a team sport? Sometimes there's no natural leader but sometimes there's already a natural leader within a group, and everybody is more comfortable just to assign them the leader or have at least someone in a leader or co leader position. There's a lot more than just a title, they address the issues first, solve problems, have teamwork, step up and take responsibility There are many solid leaders in kpop and it wouldn't make sense for some not to be the leader and lead their group.
Maknae isn't a position lol It's not optional. In korean culture, there's maknae in any sort of group of people whether it be work, kpop, school, etc. There are some people who are really attached to their leader position and take it very seriously Yunho, Eric, etc. While Taeyeon might've been the second of those, I don't think she did bad or anything. I think if a person takes it seriously and wants to be it then it's a beneficial position for the group.
Especially if all the members are fairly young. Seohyeon is the one that keeps tabs of their schedules and the one the keeps tabs of their commitements.
In other shows, everyone acknowledged that Seohyun is very strict in how their dorm is run and rules that must be followed.
She is also the most attentive when it comes to the needs of other members. She looks after everyone. Still connected to Number one, Girls Generation has not matured. They are still money makers and from the point of view of business, there is no reason to fix something that is not broken. However, part of being a leader is being able to pivot a group towards progress and growth.
It is certainly the responsibility of the leader to set a vision, the mere fact that SNSD has not grown up means Taeyeon has none. She doesn't have to be selfish in that vision. She could very well asked all the members to participate in creating one but the mere fact that Girls Generation sound has remained the same means she either failed in leading the group to come up with a vision or she failed in leading the group to implement it.
Again, it may be argued that SM is clipping their wings but it's the leader's responsibility to fight for the group. Even prior to quitting, SNSD members felt they had no leader and it made it easier for them to accept her resignation.
She did eventually stay as the leader after she told the members she was expecting them to decline her resignation. However, the mere fact that her own members felt they were functioning with not leader and things were still going smoothly meant she didn't make much of a difference as a leader.
Even after that incident, Seohyun continued functioning as she always had, the one who keeps the group together by keeping everyone in check, representing the group to the company, and keeping everything together. In fact, the leader should be the foundation of the group, the source of strength. When everything crumbles, the leader should hold it together. SNSD didn't even go through extreme controversies but she still chose to quit. Moreover, she did so at the height of SNSD's popularity.
She has had years to adjust to the role, developer her own style of leadership but she still quit. Leaders experience controversies. Even the best ones out there get caught up in rumors and mistakes that were caught on camera. Onew's middle finger to his members caused him to go on hiatus and GD's scandals are too many to mention.
But Taeyeon's diva behavior and rude comment towards nurses in a hospital she went to to take shots. She made fun of them for being on a break when she was there. She later apologized for the statement she made on the nurses. Some people credit her statements to her youth, being a young girl with not a lot of background when it comes to how hospitals work and rights of employees. Some people refuse appreciate the apology but it doesn't add to how they view Taeyeon as a leader.
Again, this is not to say that these reasons are valid and that Taeyeon is actually a bad leader. This article only aims to provide reasons why people think she is a bad leader. Whether or not you agree is just fine.
Leave comments! This article was originally published back in Thus, some info WAS outdated. There seems to be some renewed interest so I updated some parts of it to reflect recent developments.
What a load of old bollocks! It strikes me that people only make up this crap about people like Taeyeon because they are jealous of her and I can see why - she is beautiful, she can sing and dance and she is POPULAR!
By the way, Taeyeon has made more music outside of SNSD - just check the internet if you don't believe me. Making or even suggesting negative comments about anyone that you do not know personally can destroy them mentally and lead them to harm themselves.
This should not be allowed. People that do this should be ashamed of themselves. To everyone leaving a comment: Please don't use my name as yours.
You need to be uniquely identifiable. I don't know anything about this group and haven't seen them or listened to any of their song but I got sidetracked to the title of your article so I had to check it out.
And in my opinion, unless you have walked in her shoes, you are in no position to judge her or anyone else in the world. You can judge movies, music, television shows, the economy or even food but a person that you do not know personally should never be a target of your criticism.
Taeyeon is known by everyone to have one of the best voices in the intire kpop industry and her solos are some of the most popular. How can you say she has no individual identity and is outshone by everyone else? How can you say that Girls' Generation never evolved and never changed? They are the most beautiful and talented. SNSD are legends. They are the nation's girl group for a reason. No special treatment or extra activities? That she didn't shine, or that's SM didn't realize her importance?
Bullshit, Taeyeon is SM's darling, she has more solos than any other group member in the agency. The other members have outshine her? Doesn't have any special talent? Did you heard any of her solos? UR is the best song ever. Many of the topics is not about leadership, the members don't talk about her leadership, but how many groups also don't talk about their leader?
Seohyun has a mom personality, she always took care of the members, that's why she is known as the "second leader".
0コメント